What guitar pedals should I get?

With you on the Cry Baby cos I have one. You might want to try the Tech21 SansAmp GT2 instead of the Boss pedals, you wouldn't need the DS-1 and the MT-2 anyways, one would be enough. Chorus pedals are dirt cheap these days and there's loads of them out there. I've an Ashton CR30 chorus which I got for �15/$20 on a special.